Searching for valuable modern U.S. quarters among the many “regular” state quarters in circulation can be overwhelming. Most of these coins are worth just 25 cents, especially when they’re worn. However, a few stand out as rare and valuable. Here’s a guide to some of the most sought-after state quarters that could be worth much more than face value.
1. 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter: $10 to $20
The first year of the 50 State Quarters series introduced a quirky variety known as the “Spitting Horse” error, making the 1999 Delaware quarter one of the most interesting. The coin depicts Caesar Rodney riding a horse to cast a pivotal vote for independence. On some of these quarters, a raised line extends from the horse’s mouth, creating a “spitting” effect. This error was caused by a die break, and although it was once extremely rare, the price has dropped over time, with coins now selling for $10 to $20.
2. 2004-D Extra Leaf Wisconsin Quarter: $50 to $65
The 2004-D Wisconsin quarter is famous for two unique “Extra Leaf” varieties that appeared on the corn stalk design. The Extra High Leaf variety features a long leaf near the top of the stalk, while the Extra Low Leaf has one that arches across the bottom. These unusual features were first spotted shortly after the coin’s release, and although the hype has faded, the coins are still valuable, with the Extra High Leaf fetching up to $65 and the Extra Low Leaf selling for around $50.
3. 2005-P Minnesota Doubled Die Quarter: $5 to $100
The 2005-P Minnesota quarter, part of the 50 State Quarters series, features more than 60 known varieties of doubled dies. These errors, mostly showing extra images of the spruce trees on the reverse, can make the coin very valuable. The most prominent doubled dies can sell for $50 to $100, while less noticeable varieties are typically worth between $5 and $25, depending on the extent of the error.
4. 2009-D District of Columbia Doubled Die Quarter: $75
Though part of a separate program commemorating Washington D.C. and U.S. territories, the 2009-D District of Columbia quarter is often collected alongside the state quarters. The coin, featuring jazz legend Duke Ellington, is known for a dramatic doubled die error that affects his name, especially the “ELL” letters. This error can also be seen in the piano keys. These quarters are still highly sought after and typically trade for around $75.
5. 1999-S Pennsylvania Proof Silver Quarter: $35
The 1999 Pennsylvania quarter, part of the first year of the state quarter program, is a special proof coin made from 90% silver. The coin features the state motto “VIRTUE, LIBERTY, INDEPENDENCE” and has a low mintage of just 804,565 coins. Its silver content and reflective proof finish make it more valuable, with coins typically selling for around $35 or more.
6. 1999-S New Jersey Proof Silver Quarter: $30
Another rare proof coin is the 1999-S New Jersey quarter, which features a dramatic depiction of George Washington crossing the Delaware River. Like the Pennsylvania proof, it is made of 90% silver and has a low mintage. The sharp details and polished finish make this coin appealing to collectors, with flawless examples fetching around $30.
Honorable Mentions
While error coins dominate this list, there are other noteworthy state quarters that are also worth money. These coins stand out for their lower mintage or unique features, though they might not be as famous as the error varieties listed above.
- 1999-D New Jersey: 299,028,000 minted
- 2000-D South Carolina: 566,208,000 minted
- 2000-D New Hampshire: 495,976,000 minted
- 2001-D New York: 619,640,000 minted
- 2001-D North Carolina: 427,876,000 minted
- 2003-P Maine: 217,400,000 minted
- 2004-P Michigan: 233,800,000 minted
- 2005-P Kansas: 263,400,000 minted
- 2005-D West Virginia: 356,200,000 minted
These coins can be valuable, especially when found in excellent condition or as part of a well-curated collection.
Conclusion
While most state quarters are worth just their face value, some rare varieties and proof coins can be worth much more. From quirky errors like the “Spitting Horse” to special silver proof coins, these quarters provide an opportunity to find hidden treasures in your pocket change. Keep an eye out for these rare varieties — they might just be worth more than you think!
